Digital First Dentistry › Managing existing restorations

Free verifiable CPD · 1 hour

Managing existing restorations: monitor, repair or replace

About this CPD

Format
Free online self-study, about 1 hour: this page, the required reading below, a five-question check and a short feedback form.
CPD hours
1 hour of verifiable CPD
Aim
To help dental professionals assess existing restorations systematically, choose between monitoring, refurbishment, repair and replacement, and involve patients in those decisions using records taken over time.
Objectives
  • Explain why the management of existing restorations is a large part of everyday restorative dentistry.
  • Assess an existing restoration using structured criteria, such as the revised FDI criteria.
  • Compare monitoring, refurbishment, repair and replacement, and the case for minimal intervention.
  • Use photographs and scans over time to show patients how a restoration is changing and to support shared decisions.
GDC development outcomes
  • C: Maintenance and development of knowledge and skill within your field of practice.
  • A: Effective communication with patients, the dental team and others across dentistry, including obtaining valid consent, dealing with complaints and raising concerns when patients are at risk.
Provider and quality assurance
Provided by Bhavin Associates Ltd (company 07713563). Quality assured by Dr Bhavin Bhatt BDS MFGDP RCS (Eng), GDC 76358, for Bhavin Associates Ltd. See how CPD is quality assured.

The size of the problem

Much of restorative dentistry is not new disease but old work. A 2018 review of studies on why direct restorations are placed found that, of 86,720 restorations reported, 57.3% were replacements of existing restorations rather than new placements (Eltahlah et al., Journal of Dentistry 2018). Every replacement removes more tooth, and each cycle brings a tooth closer to a crown, a root canal treatment or extraction.

Deciding when, where and how to intervene on an existing restoration is one of the most common judgements in general practice, yet it is often made on a single visit's impression, with little record of how the restoration looked last year.

Assessing a restoration systematically

The FDI World Dental Federation criteria, first published in 2007 and revised in 2022 to 2023 (Hickel et al., Clinical Oral Investigations), score restorations across functional, biological and aesthetic properties. Scores 1 to 3 describe clinically acceptable restorations, including those needing only refurbishment; score 4 indicates repair; score 5 indicates replacement. Using structured criteria makes decisions more consistent and easier to explain and record.

Look in particular at:

  • Function: fracture of material, loss of retention, marginal adaptation, contacts, form, occlusion and wear.
  • Biology: caries at the margin, fracture or cracks in the tooth, sensitivity, and the health of adjacent tissues.
  • Aesthetics: surface, marginal staining and colour, which on their own rarely justify replacement.

Monitor, refurbish, repair or replace

  1. Monitor when the restoration is acceptable or a defect is minor and stable. Record a baseline so change can be judged next time.
  2. Refurbish (polish, reshape, reseal) when surface or margin problems can be corrected without removing material.
  3. Repair when a localised defect can be fixed by adding material, preserving the rest of the restoration and the tooth.
  4. Replace when the restoration has failed in a way that repair cannot address, such as extensive caries, gross fracture or loss of retention.

Minimal intervention favours the least invasive option that resolves the problem. Marginal staining alone is not evidence of caries, and replacing a restoration because it looks old is hard to justify.

Using records over time

Most problems with existing restorations develop slowly: a chipped marginal ridge, a widening ditch at a margin, a crack line, wear of the opposing tooth. Without a record of how the restoration looked before, both clinician and patient struggle to judge whether it is getting worse.

A photograph or intraoral scan at the check-up gives a baseline. Repeated at later visits, it shows whether a defect is stable or progressing, which turns a judgement call into a shared observation. Patients who can see that a margin has opened since last year understand why repair now may avoid a larger problem later; patients who see that it has not changed understand why monitoring is reasonable.

Talking with the patient

  • Show the restoration on a photograph or scan, and compare with the previous record where you have one.
  • Explain the options, including monitoring, with the likely consequences of each, including doing nothing.
  • Record the assessment, the options discussed, the patient's understanding and their decision.

Putting it into practice

For one month, record a structured assessment and a photograph or scan of every restoration you consider replacing. Before replacing, ask: could this be monitored, refurbished or repaired instead? Review the decisions with a colleague at the end of the month.

Required reading

Read these short pages as part of this CPD:

Doing this as a team? Send it to your nurses and hygienists: WhatsApp · Email

Check your learning

Answer all five questions. You need four correct to continue. You can try again.

1. In the 2018 review by Eltahlah and colleagues, roughly what proportion of direct restorations reported were replacements?

2. In the revised FDI criteria, what does a score of 4 indicate?

3. Which finding, on its own, rarely justifies replacing a restoration?

4. What is the main value of a photograph or scan of an existing restoration at the check-up?

5. Which approach best reflects minimal intervention for a small localised defect in an otherwise sound restoration?

← All free CPD modules

Get the white paper and the starter guide

Free. Enter your email and both open straight away.

Tell us more (optional)

We use your email to send these resources, and updates only if you tick the box. Never shared. Unsubscribe any time.

Written by Dr Bhavin Bhatt BDS MFGDP RCS (Eng), GDC 76358 with AI drafting assistance · Facts checked 16 November 2026 · Editorial policy · Independence · Report an error